uncut raw emerald crystals and gemstones

How to recognize an emerald?

Emerald, a captivating gemstone, has fascinated jewelry and mineral lovers for centuries for its bewitching green color. This precious gem owes its distinctive brilliance to the presence of chromium and vanadium in its crystalline structure. Emeralds are not only superb ornaments, they also have great cultural and historical value.


Beware, however, as the market is saturated with counterfeits and inferior stones. The aim of this article is to help you distinguish a genuine emerald from its many imitations, by highlighting the criteria of color, clarity and provenance that characterize this gemstone.

uncut emerald and uncut gemstone crystals

What is an emerald? A jewel of mineralogy

Emerald is a precious mineral belonging to the silicate family, more specifically to the beryl group. It occupies a special place in mineralogy due to its unique characteristics and rarity. Its brilliance and transparency make it one of the most coveted gemstones, and it is often set in high-quality jewelry.


The color of emerald can vary from a pale yellowish green to a deep bluish green. The bright green is the most sought-after color in emerald, which generally makes it more expensive. In the world of mineralogy, emerald is also famous for its inclusions, known as emerald gardens, which are internal formations of minerals or liquids. While some inclusions can diminish the gem's value, they are also sometimes considered proof of its authenticity.


Emerald is one of the four traditional gemstones, alongside diamond, sapphire and ruby. Associated with wealth, high-quality emeralds are among the most expensive in the world, especially if they are free of visible inclusions. Overall, the emerald's position in the gemstone world is very high, both in terms of financial value and cultural significance.


Emerald's physical properties: Unique brilliance

Emerald stands out in the world of gemstones not only for its brilliance and green color, but also for its unique physical properties among silicates.

  1. Color: The characteristic green color can vary from very light to dark.
  2. Hardness: On the Mohs scale, emeralds have a hardness of 7.5 to 8, making them relatively hard but more prone to scratching than diamonds, sapphires and rubies.
  3. Fracture: Emeralds generally have internal inclusions and fissures, making them more fragile.
  4. Brilliance: Emeralds have a vitreous luster.

According to followers of lithotherapy, a non-scientific approach that attributes healing properties to stones and minerals, emerald has many virtues. This green gem is said to promote emotional balance, help clear the mind and strengthen love and fidelity in a relationship. It is also said to improve vision, strengthen the immune system and reduce stress.


It's important to note that his beliefs are not supported by scientific evidence, and that lithotherapy should not replace traditional medical treatment.

Chemical properties of emerald

Emerald, an aluminum beryllium silicate, owes its color to the presence of chromium and vanadium ions. This gemstone is sensitive to sudden temperature changes and can be damaged by aggressive chemicals.

Real or fake emeralds: how to tell the difference?

Emerald is a green gemstone with a wide variety of inclusions known as the emerald garden. These inclusions make each stone unique and are not always visible to the naked eye. They are apparent when we observe them with a jeweler's loupe. The purer the emerald, the more difficult they are to find. On the other hand, the absence of blemishes or irregular patterns could mean that the emerald is glass or crystal. Here is a series of tests that can help you recognize a genuine emerald.

  1. To the naked eye, emerald is usually dark green or blue-green.
  2. Using a jeweler's magnifying glass, look at the emerald through an oblique light beam to find inclusions.
  3. If the stone produces flashes of light or a rainbow, it is not an emerald.
  4. If the edges of the facets of the stone are flayed, it is not an emerald.
  5. Emeralds do not have several layers on top of each other.
  6. There's no such thing as a "cheap" emerald, just one of the four gemstones along with ruby, sapphire and, of course, diamond.

The evaluation of an emerald by a gemologist remains the surest analysis for determining the gem's authenticity and obtaining all its characteristics on a certificate.

Synthetic or natural: Two types of emerald

The comparison between synthetic and natural emeralds is of constant interest to gem lovers, due to their unique characteristics and distinct origins. A synthetic emerald, also known as a laboratory-created emerald, is artificially produced by man, while natural emeralds are formed in the earth over long periods of time.


The main difference lies in their origin. Natural emeralds are born of complex geological processes, often associated with the presence of minerals and extreme pressures in the earth's crust. Synthetic emeralds, on the other hand, are manufactured under high pressure and high temperature (HPHT) conditions in the laboratory. Today's techniques also enable inclusions to be reproduced.


Ultimately, the choice between a synthetic and a natural emerald depends on personal preference and budgetary considerations, since both share similarities in chemical composition and appearance. Synthetic emeralds often offer a lower cost, while natural emeralds are prized for their rarity and provenance. The damage caused by mining can also influence the choice of a person concerned about environmental issues.


The value of an emerald: A precious investment

The value of an emerald is determined by several key factors that play a crucial role in its appreciation on the jewelry market. These factors are essential for collectors' gemstone investments.


Like diamonds, emeralds are valued according to 4 criteria: color, clarity, cut and carat. Generally speaking, a bright, transparent emerald with a few visible inclusions will be worth more than a cloudy emerald with many small inclusions.


The quality of the color is paramount. An emerald's green hue must be intense, uniform and pleasing to the eye to be of great value. True emeralds are dichroic. They appear blue-green from one angle and slightly yellow-green from the other. The stronger the dichroism, with two distinct colors, the higher the emerald's quality.


The transparency of the stone is another crucial element. The fewer inclusions or imperfections visible to the naked eye, the more precious the emerald.


Size and weight are also important. Large, well-cut emeralds have a higher value, especially when used in jewelry such as necklaces.


Finally, an emerald's origin can also influence its market value. Emeralds from regions renowned for their quality, such as Colombia, may be more prized on the market.


  • EMERALD QUALITY 
Poor quality emerald

BAD

Fuzzy, lots of bubbles

and small inclusions.

Medium Quality Emerald

AVERAGE

Slightly blurred brightness, numerous and visible inclusions.


Good quality emerald

GOOD

Bright sparkle, inclusions and bubbles

visible in small groups.

Pure quality emerald

HIGH

Very bright, with very slight incursions and virtually no bubbles.

The origin of emeralds

The first emeralds were discovered in Egypt's mines 3,500 years ago, becoming over time a symbol of Egyptian national pride. When Queen Cleopatra, Egypt's last pharaoh, took power in 47 B.C., she seized all the country's deposits in order to maintain control over this magnificent green stone, which she loved more than anything else. American actress Elizabeth Taylor, who played Cleopatra on the silver screen in 1963, owns an extensive collection of emerald jewelry, which goes wonderfully well with her green eyes.


Three-picture picture with the American actress Elizabeth Taylor adorned with emerald jewels, the close-up hair jewel and a scene from the film Cleopatra by Joseph L. Mankiewicz.

The deposits of the world 

Egypt's emerald deposits have long since been exhausted. Today, high-quality emeralds come mainly from deposits in Colombia and Zambia. Colombian emeralds are particularly renowned for their brilliant green color and purity. There are also deposits in Afghanistan, Brazil, Madagascar, Pakistan, Russia and Zimbabwe.

To deepen your knowledge of emerald, its unique properties and origins, the"Fascinating Emerald" workshop is offered by iGEM, the Montreal Gemmological Institute.

The emerald, a jewel to recognize

To identify a genuine emerald from its imitations, focus on the criteria of color and clarity that characterize this gemstone. Its color can vary from pale yellowish-green to deep bluish-green, but bright green is the most sought-after. If the stone produces flashes of light or a rainbow when viewed through a beam of light, it is not an emerald. Emerald's inclusions or gardens are not always visible to the naked eye, but they guarantee its authenticity. Consult us for an accurate appraisal of your gemstone. Our expertise with gems guarantees your peace of mind.

FAQ - Frequently asked questions

1. How to recognize an emerald?

Recognizing a genuine emerald can be a challenge, since there are so many imitations on the market. Genuine emeralds have a deep, intense green color, often with internal inclusions invisible to the naked eye. They have a vitreous luster but do not sparkle like a diamond. They are relatively hard, but can be scratched. High-quality emeralds are expensive. If the price seems too low, chances are the stone is a counterfeit.


2. What is the price of a natural emerald vs. a synthetic emerald?

The price of a natural emerald varies considerably depending on several factors, including the stone's quality, origin and rarity. High-quality natural emeralds can be very expensive, reaching thousands or even tens of thousands of dollars per carat, and even more for exceptional gems. In contrast, synthetic or laboratory-created emeralds are less expensive than their natural counterparts. Their cost depends on the quality of manufacture, size and other characteristics, but they are considerably more affordable. High-quality synthetic emeralds can still cost several hundred dollars per carat.


3. Is the emerald created in the laboratory a real emerald?

Yes, laboratory-created emerald is real emerald, but it is man-made by recreating the geological conditions under which natural emeralds are formed in nature. Synthetic emerald has the same chemical composition and physical properties as natural emerald, but is artificial in relation to its geological origin.


4. What is the significance of an emerald engagement ring?

Less common than the diamond engagement ring, the emerald engagement ring symbolizes eternal love, hope, renewal, wisdom, patience, balance and mutual support in individual and marital development. It's important to note that the meaning of an emerald engagement ring can vary according to culture and personal beliefs. Some simply choose this gem for its beauty and uniqueness.

Still have questions? We can help you.

Get an online consultation with one of our jewelers today.